16 Nov 2026 Standard 10 per cent penalty on property purchases not always reasonable: changes in the housing market play a role in the Court’s decision to reduce the penalty!

Anyone who buys a property but is unable to pay the purchase price on time risks, under the standard model deed of sale, a contractual penalty of 10 per cent of the purchase price. However, this does not mean that the seller is entitled to the full amount in all cases. The actual loss, the circumstances of the case and the consequences for the buyer may also play a role in assessing whether the penalty should be reduced. This follows from a recent judgment of the Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal dated 29 September 2026 (ECLI:NL:GHARL:2026:6289).

What were the facts of the case?

In 2023, two sisters purchased a property for €380,000. The contract of sale stipulated that, in the event of termination due to an attributable breach, a penalty of 10 per cent of the purchase price would be payable.

The sisters were unable to pay the purchase price by the agreed date. They were dependent on a gift from their parents to finance the purchase, which was to be paid from the equity in their parents’ home. A priority determination procedure proved necessary for the distribution of that equity. Although the notary had informed them of the steps to be taken even before the conclusion of the contract of sale, they had failed to apply for this procedure in good time.

The seller served notice of default on the sisters and subsequently terminated the contract of sale. He claimed the contractual penalty of €38,000, which was paid from the bank guarantee via the notary.

The sisters disagreed with this and claimed reimbursement of the penalty. After the court had dismissed their claim, they lodged an appeal. They argued, amongst other things, that the penalty was disproportionate to the seller’s loss. The seller had, in fact, eventually sold the property to another buyer for €398,555, which was €18,555 more than the original purchase price.

When can a contractual penalty be moderated?

Under Article 6:94 of the Dutch Civil Code, the court may moderate a contractual penalty if equity clearly so requires. A high threshold applies here: the application of the penalty clause must, in the specific circumstances, lead to an excessive and therefore unacceptable result.

In making this assessment, the court does not merely consider the relationship between the actual loss and the agreed penalty. The nature of the contract, the content and scope of the penalty clause, and the circumstances under which it is invoked are also relevant.

The Court of Appeal’s ruling

The Court of Appeal first held that the buyers had failed to fulfil their obligation to take possession of the property on time. Although the Court of Appeal accepted that there was no question of bad faith, the buyers had not taken action sufficiently in good time to initiate the necessary priority ranking procedure for the distribution of the surplus value of the parental home. They had already received information on this matter from the notary prior to the conclusion of the contract of sale. Consequently, they should reasonably have been able to foresee that the financing would not be finalised in time. Their inexperience and any reliance on advice from their financial adviser were, in principle, at their own risk and expense.

The fact that, by their own account, they would have been able to pay the purchase price nine months later did not detract from the seller’s interest in performance on the agreed date.

The Court of Appeal therefore saw no reason to assume that the penalty was not due. The question was whether it was reasonable to uphold the full penalty.

In assessing the penalty, the Court of Appeal focused specifically on the financial consequences of the breach for the seller. The property was ultimately sold for €398,555. This resulted in a higher sale price of €18,555 compared with the original purchase price. The seller had estimated his loss resulting from the breach at €11,455.65. That loss had not been substantively contested during the proceedings. On balance, the seller had therefore realised a financial benefit of €7,099.35. The Court of Appeal then also took into account the liquidated legal costs in the first instance of €3,931 in its assessment. After deducting this amount, a benefit of €3,168.35 remained.

In this regard, the Court of Appeal referred to Article 6:100 of the Dutch Civil Code, under which a benefit arising from the same event must, in certain circumstances, be taken into account when assessing damages. The Court of Appeal considered it reasonable to take the higher sale proceeds into account when assessing whether the agreed penalty could be upheld.

However, this did not mean that the seller had not suffered any loss. He had himself purchased another property and ran the risk of owing a penalty of €47,300 should he fail to take possession of it on time. He had therefore had to make efforts to find a new buyer and had been dependent on the willingness of his bank and his own seller to facilitate the transfer of his new property. The Court of Appeal took into account the uncertainty and inconvenience this had caused.

The most striking consideration in the judgment concerned the standard penalty clause in the model deed of sale.
The Court of Appeal pointed out that the customary percentage of 10 per cent originated in a period when house prices were considerably lower and properties were sold less quickly. In the years preceding the dispute, house prices had risen sharply. Moreover, in the tight housing market, properties could be resold relatively quickly, sometimes even for a higher price.

According to the Court of Appeal, this reflects a change in societal views regarding the reasonableness of the amount of the standard penalty clause and its practical implications. The Court of Appeal noted that the practical implications may differ again in the future, should the housing market turn.

The buyers’ circumstances also played a role. The case involved two young private individuals who were at the start of their studies and careers. The liability of €38,000 would significantly restrict their financial capacity. Furthermore, they had not negotiated the standard clause.

The Court of Appeal did not attribute decisive weight to these circumstances individually, but did take them into account when assessing whether the full penalty would lead to an unacceptable outcome in this case.

Taking all factors into account, the Court of Appeal ruled that the full payment of the €38,000 penalty would lead to an excessive and unacceptable outcome for the purchasers. Conversely, excessive mitigation would undermine the purpose of the penalty clause. After all, the penalty serves not only to fix the amount of damages, but also as an incentive to perform the contract and to prevent disputes over the extent of the damage. The Court of Appeal therefore reduced the penalty to €10,000.

Conclusion

This judgment makes it clear that a contractual penalty of 10 per cent in the event of failure to take possession of a property does not necessarily have to remain in full force under all circumstances. Although the court must exercise restraint in reducing the penalty under Article 6:94 of the Dutch Civil Code, factors such as the actual loss, a higher sale price following termination, the consequences for the buyer and the circumstances in the housing market may provide grounds for reducing the penalty.

The considerations regarding the housing market are particularly noteworthy in this regard. The Court of Appeal does not state that the customary percentage of 10 per cent is no longer appropriate. However, it makes it clear that the reasonableness of its application may be assessed partly in the light of changed market conditions.

For buyers, the ruling provides grounds to carefully examine, in the event of a substantial contractual penalty, whether a reduction is justifiable. For sellers, it remains important to provide a clear account not only of the breach but also of its consequences and the damage they have suffered.

Would you like to know more about contractual penalty clauses when buying or selling a property, or would you like to know what options are available to you if a contract of sale is not fulfilled? Please feel free to contact one of our solicitors, with no obligation. We would be delighted to assist you!

mr. Marion van Acker, Attorney-at-law

SPEE advocaten & mediation Maastricht