An employee on long-term sick leave sought a court order to terminate his dormant employment contract. However, the employer refused to cooperate, arguing that the employment contract had in fact already ended because the employee had started working eight hours a week elsewhere. If a transition payment were nevertheless due, the employer contended that a substantial amount in reintegration costs should be deducted from it. You can read the court’s ruling on this matter here:
Eight hours’ work elsewhere does not terminate the employment contract
The employee had been on sick leave since August 2021. The UWV found that the employer had not done enough to facilitate the employee’s return to work and therefore extended the obligation to continue paying wages until August 2024. After that, the employee no longer carried out any work for this employer. The parties discussed the termination of the employment contract but could not agree on the amount of the transition payment.
Following the end of the employer’s obligation to continue paying wages, the employee – who is 80–100 per cent incapacitated for work – accepted, with the UWV’s consent, paid work for eight hours a week with another employer. According to the subdistrict court, this did not mean that he had terminated his existing employment contract. He had not expressly terminated that contract and, given the circumstances, the employer was not entitled to regard his new work as a notice of termination either.
Employer must cooperate with the termination of a dormant employment contract
The employment contract therefore still existed, whilst the employee was no longer performing any work and the employer was no longer required to pay wages. This constituted a dormant employment contract. Under the so-called Xella case law, an employer must, in principle, cooperate with a proposal from the employee to terminate such an employment relationship by mutual consent, subject to payment of compensation equivalent to the transition payment.
The employer initially wished to await the outcome of separate proceedings concerning the wage penalty imposed. The subdistrict court judge found that this was not a reason to allow the employment contract to continue. Nor did the fact that the employee works eight hours a week elsewhere, in the absence of further explanation from the employer, lead to the conclusion that there were genuine opportunities for reintegration with this employer.
The employer must cooperate with the termination within seven days. It must then pay a transition payment of €24,768.01 gross.
Reintegration costs may not be deducted
The employer wished to deduct €12,086.89 in reintegration costs from the payment. In doing so, it relied on the Construction & Infrastructure Collective Labour Agreement and the rules governing the deduction of costs from the transition payment.
That argument was unsuccessful. For the majority of the costs, it had not been established or shown that they had been itemised and communicated to the employee in writing prior to their incurrence. That condition remains applicable, even where an exception to the requirement for the employee’s written consent might exist for certain costs. Nor were the conditions for deduction met in respect of the remaining costs.
Leave taken during sickness cannot be deducted without consent
Finally, the employer argued that the employee had taken 40 hours’ leave in excess. Among other things, the employer had deducted collective holiday entitlement and ATV hours from his balance whilst he was on sick leave. The employee disputed that he had consented to this.
The subdistrict court ruled that sick days can only count as holiday days if the employee consents to this in the specific case. The employer had not demonstrated that any agreements had been made regarding the deduction of these hours. It must therefore draw up a new final statement without deducting the 104 hours at the centre of the dispute, and pay out the resulting balance. The employer’s counterclaim regarding the excess leave hours taken was dismissed.
You can read the full judgment here: ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2026:6826, Rechtbank Overijssel, 12300489 \ EJ VERZ 26-215
Conclusion
This judgement demonstrates that working a few hours for another employer does not automatically terminate a dormant employment contract. The applicable conditions and agreements made are also decisive when it comes to deducting reintegration costs and writing off leave during sick leave.
Are you an employer or an employee and do you have questions about dormant employment contracts, return-to-work arrangements following illness or other employment law issues? SPEE lawyers & mediation can advise you.
Martine E.V. van Krieken-Boersma, LL.M., Ph.D., solicitor